
To record HMRC tax payments in your bookkeeping, post each payment against the liability it pays off, such as the VAT control account or the corporation tax creditor, rather than to an expense. The cost of the tax was already recorded when it arose, so treating the payment as a new expense counts it twice and makes your profit look smaller than it really is.
Bank feeds make this mistake easy, because a payment to "HMRC" looks the same whatever tax it is for. Below is a one-page map of where each type of HMRC payment belongs, with a worked month for a small company.
Key takeaways
- Most HMRC payments clear a liability; they are not expenses at the moment you pay.
- Give VAT, PAYE and corporation tax their own balance sheet accounts.
- A sole trader's Self Assessment payments are drawings, not business costs.
- A director's personal tax paid by the company goes to the director's loan account.
- Penalties are not tax-deductible, so keep them separate.
What is a tax liability account?
A tax liability account is a balance sheet account that shows how much tax your business owes HMRC at a point in time. It goes up when tax becomes due, for example when you post a VAT return or a payroll journal, and goes down when you pay. If everything is posted correctly, the balance on each account should match what HMRC says you owe. Our guide to the chart of accounts explains where these accounts sit.
Where each HMRC payment belongs
| Payment to HMRC | Account it clears | Expense when paid? | Where the cost was recorded |
|---|---|---|---|
| VAT return payment | VAT control (liability) | No | Not a cost; VAT collected and reclaimed both sit in the control account |
| PAYE and National Insurance | PAYE and NIC control (liability) | No | Payroll journal: gross wages and employer NIC |
| Corporation tax | Corporation tax creditor (liability) | No | Year-end tax charge in the profit and loss account |
| CIS deductions paid by a contractor | CIS control (liability) | No | Subcontractor invoices at gross value |
| Sole trader Self Assessment | Drawings | No, never deductible | Not a business cost at all |
| Director's personal tax paid by the company | Director's loan account | No | A debt the director owes the company |
| Late filing or payment penalty | Penalties (expense, disallowed for tax) | Yes in the accounts, but added back for tax | Recorded when charged |
HMRC gives the payment references for each tax on GOV.UK, for example on its pages on how to pay VAT and pay corporation tax. Using the right reference matters as much as the bookkeeping, because a payment with the wrong reference can sit on the wrong tax account at HMRC.
Step by step: posting an HMRC payment
- Identify the tax and period. Use the payment reference or your remittance note. A PAYE reference shows the tax month; a corporation tax reference is specific to the accounting period.
- Check the liability is already in the books. The VAT return, payroll journal or corporation tax charge should be posted first.
- Match the bank line to the liability account. In most software you create a bank payment or transfer coded to the control account, not to an expense category.
- Check the balance afterwards. After paying a VAT return in full, the part of the VAT control account relating to that period should be zero.
- Investigate leftovers. A small balance usually means a penalty, interest, a part payment or a payment posted to the wrong period. Clear it properly instead of parking it in a suspense account.
Worked example: one month at a small company
Illustrative example with invented figures. "Fenwick Studio Ltd" is a design company with a 31 March year end. In early February 2027 its bank feed shows three payments to HMRC:
- £4,180 for VAT for the quarter to 31 December 2026. The VAT return was posted in January, leaving £4,180 on the VAT control account. The payment clears it to zero.
- £1,960 for PAYE for the tax month to 5 February 2027. The January payroll journal had already put £1,960 into the PAYE and NIC control account. The payment clears it.
- £2,300 for a director's Self Assessment, paid from the company account by mistake. This is the director's personal tax, so it is posted to the director's loan account as money the director owes the company.
Had the bookkeeper coded all three to a "Taxes" expense, the profit and loss account would show £8,440 of extra costs that do not exist, the VAT and PAYE balances would look unpaid, and the director's loan account would be understated. That last point matters, because an overdrawn director's loan account can have its own tax consequences, explained on GOV.UK's directors' loans page.
Common mistakes
- One "HMRC" account for everything. You cannot see which tax is unpaid. Use one account per tax.
- Recording VAT repayments as income. They are refunds of VAT already in the control account.
- Expensing corporation tax. It is a charge on profit, booked at year end, not a running cost.
- Hiding penalties in general expenses. They must be added back for tax, so they need their own account.
- Skipping the monthly check. A quick look at each control account during your bank reconciliation catches errors before year end.
How we can help
We are a London-based practice with fixed monthly fees. Our bookkeeping service starts from £150 a month and includes reconciling your VAT, PAYE and corporation tax accounts, and our limited company packages start from £75 a month. See our pricing or contact us.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I record HMRC tax payments in my bookkeeping?
Post each payment against the liability account it settles, not to an expense. A VAT payment clears the VAT control account, a PAYE payment clears the PAYE and National Insurance control account, and a corporation tax payment clears the corporation tax creditor. The cost was recorded earlier, when the tax arose, so the payment only reduces what you owe.
Is a VAT payment to HMRC a business expense?
Not for a VAT-registered business using standard VAT accounting. The VAT you collected from customers was never your income, and the VAT you reclaim is not your cost, so both sit in the VAT control account. The payment to HMRC simply settles the balance. Businesses on the Flat Rate Scheme handle VAT differently, so check with your accountant.
Where does a sole trader record Self Assessment tax payments?
As drawings, not as a business expense. Income tax and Class 4 National Insurance are personal taxes on your profit, so paying them from the business account is like taking money out for yourself. Recording them as an expense would understate your profit, and HMRC does not allow income tax as a deduction.
Are HMRC penalties tax-deductible?
No. Penalties for late filing or late payment are not allowable for income tax or corporation tax, so record them in a separate account and make sure they are added back in the tax computation. Interest charged on late tax follows different rules depending on the tax, so ask your accountant how to treat it rather than guessing.
How do I record a VAT repayment from HMRC?
If HMRC owes you money, the VAT control account will show a debit balance after the return is posted. When the repayment reaches your bank, post it against that same control account, which brings it back towards zero. Do not record a VAT repayment as income, because it is a refund of VAT you paid on purchases.
Related reading
How Berber Accounts & Tax helps
We are a London-based, specialist gig-economy and MTD accounting practice working with fixed monthly fees. If you would like this handled for you rather than doing it yourself, we can help.
Schedule a consultation →Written by the Berber Accounts & Tax team, 124 City Road, London EC1V 2NX, United Kingdom.
Last reviewed: 10 November 2026.
This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Speak to a qualified accountant about your own circumstances before acting on it.
